True Crime w/ Anna Templeton – Cases That Made Me Double Check Every Door Before Sleeping

April 13, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #AnnaTempleton –

Tonight’s cases will make you question how safe your home really is… because in every single one of these stories, the danger wasn’t outside… it was already inside.

As someone who consumes and creates a LOT of true crime, there’s a certain type of case that never really leaves you. Not the ones that happen in dark alleyways or random locations… but the ones that happen inside someone’s home — the one place that’s supposed to be safe. The following cases are some of the most unsettling home invasion cases I’ve come across… the kind that make you double check your doors, your windows… and every noise you hear at night.

Kelsi Davies – Psychic Opens 5 Haunted eBay Dolls w/ Ouija Board | Gone Wrong

April 12, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #KelsiDavies –

Kelsi Davies and @druhawk open an eBay mystery box with 5 extremely haunted dolls inside… see what paranormal and poltergeist activity they caught on camera! They even do a ouija board with these spirits to see what they have to say.

Two Girls One Ghost – Haunted Doll Room | The Rhodes Hotel (Ep 368)

April 12, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #TwoGirlsOneGhost –

Tucked away in a tiny Indiana town, the Rhodes Hotel has lived many lives since 1893. What began as a glamorous Victorian inn during the gas boom era transformed into a brothel and speakeasy when times got tough. These days, it’s known for something much darker. Guests report footsteps in empty halls, full conversations with no one there, shadow figures lingering just out of sight, and the unmistakable feeling of being watched… or even grabbed.

Avery After Dark – My House Is So Haunted, No One Would Buy It for $1…

April 10, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #AveryAfterDark –

You read that right, a house so haunted that when the owner tried to sell it to the town for 1 dollar – they refused. She wanted to be rid of the place but the reputation of the house had been circulating for years.

Rattled & Shook and DEAD Talks Podcast – Death, Real Estate, and Scary Stories

April 10, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #RattledAndShook – #DEADTalksPodcast –

Episode 129: Meredith is joined by her friend Dave Ferrugio, host and creator of DEAD Talks, to discuss real estate, what happens after you die, and the number 100. All pretty important concepts.

Snarled – It Followed Me Home // Something Scary

April 10, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #Snarled –

Sometimes it’s not the shadows outside that haunt you but what slips inside just when you think you’re safe. The things that follow you home don’t knock, don’t wait, and don’t ask permission. They linger, patientl watching, and sometimes you only realize they’re there when it’s too late to be saved.

Morbid – Episode 774: Tillie Klimek: Mrs. Bluebeard of Chicago

April 9, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #Morbid –

Chicago in the 1920s is often remembered for the rise of organized crime and its larger‑than‑life leaders like Al Capone and Johnny Torrio. While these men shaped the city’s identity, their infamy was rivaled—at least for a time—by a group of young women whose murderous acts dominated headlines nationwide. Among them was Tillie Klimek, believed to have killed as many as seven people, including four husbands, between 1914 and 1921. Her sensational crimes and trial captivated the public and filled front pages for years.

Two Girls One Ghost – They Visited After Death | Ghost Stories & Visits From Loved Ones (x326)

April 9, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #TwoGirlsOneGhost –

Connection doesn’t end with death, and some relationships begin before you even meet… We’re sharing listener stories of loved ones reaching through the vale and across time and space, through signs, dream visits, and unexplainable moments. Sometimes in beautiful ways and sometimes in ways that are a little more eerie than comforting.

Rattled & Shook and Two Girls One Ghost – We Stayed in a Haunted Hotel Room… with a Ghost

April 9, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #RattledandShook – #TwoGirlsOneGhost –

Episode 124: Meredith travels to Chattanooga, Tennessee to join Sabrina from “Two Girls One Ghost” and stay in haunted ROOM 311 of the Read House Hotel. Spoooooky. Legend says the ghost of Annalisa Netherly haunts the halls. Will they make it through the night? Will they watch “Heated Rivalry” with a nearly 100-year-old ghost? Tune in and see. But don’t touch Meredith’s toes. That’s OFF LIMITS. Stop it.

Heart Starts Pounding – Why You Should Never Trust a Friendly Stranger. Seriously.

April 9, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #HeartStartsPounding –

A college student gets into what she thinks is her rideshare. A speech therapist spends years pretending to be someone’s mother. And a backpacker in Singapore accepts a stranger’s offer to split a hotel room…then never calls home. Three stories about the people who slipped through the cracks. By the time anyone realized something was wrong, it was already too late.

True Crime w/ Anna Templeton – He Spent $200,000 On A Cam Girl… Then Killed His Family

April 8, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #AnnaTempleton –

He spent over $200,000 on a cam girl he had never met… Then he murdered his entire family.

This is the case of Grant Amato — one of the most disturbing true crime cases involving obsession, online fantasy, and family murder.

Scarlett and Shotzi – We Stayed In A Haunted Airbnb

April 8, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #ScarlettandShotzi –

This week on our Chamber of Horrors we head to St. Augustine Florida, one of the most haunted cities in America, to investigate a century old Airbnb. Joined by Priscilla Kelly, Zachary Wentz, and Kross, we stepped into what we thought might just be a gimmicky haunted stay, but what we experienced quickly proved otherwise.

Avery After Dark – Authorities Terrified of This Haunted House in the Woods…

April 8, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #AveryAfterDark –

This episode is on the REAL Black Forest Haunting in CO. A family moves into a beautiful cabin in the middle of the woods. But they quickly begin to notice strange activity in and around the home. Classical music in the woods, the sounds of chains rattling.

Lauren the Mortician – What Is Natural Burial? (And Why It’s So Complicated Now)

April 8, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #LaurentheMortician –

Natural burial sounds simple… but is it actually legal? And why does it sometimes cost MORE? EDUCATIONAL MORTUARY DISCUSSIONS …

In this video, I’m breaking down what natural burial really is, what it actually looks like in real life, and why the funeral industry—and cemeteries—moved away from it in the first place.

Avery After Dark – He Watched His Girlfriend Get Kidnapped… The Angela Hammond Mystery

April 8, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #AveryAfterDark –

In 1991, the quiet midwestern town of Clinton, Missouri became the center of one of the most haunting unsolved abductions in America… the disappearance of Angela Hammond.

Angela was just 20 years old when she called her fiancé from a payphone late at night—completely unaware that someone was watching her. During that call, she described a strange truck circling the area. Moments later, her fiancé, Rob Shafer, heard her scream.

Morbid – Episode 773: The Rescue of Baby Jessica McClure

April 8, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #Morbid –

On October 14, 1987, Reba McClure and her eighteen-month-old daughter, Jessica, stopped by the Midland, Texas home of her sister for a visit. As Reba sat in the backyard watching Jessica play with some neighborhood children, she heard the phone ring and went inside to answer it. When McClure returned to the backyard a few minutes later, she saw the other children staring at the ground on the far-side of the yard, but Jessica was nowhere to be seen.

Lights Out – They Said God Commanded It… The Mormon ‘Revelation’ Murders

April 6, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #LightsOut –

The Lafferty case unveils a cryptic and disturbing narrative surrounding brothers Dan and Ron Lafferty — once devout members of the LDS Church who splintered off to form their own extremist sect, “The School of the Prophets.” Their descent into fanaticism culminated in the brutal 1984 murders of Brenda Lafferty and her 18‑month‑old daughter Erica, killings they claimed were commanded by “divine revelation.”

True Crime w/ Anna Templeton – A Normal Night Turned Into a 7 Hour Home Invasion

April 6, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #AnnaTempleton –

She was followed home from a supermarket… and held hostage for seven hours. What happened inside that house became one of the most disturbing home invasion cases in modern true crime.

This is the story of the Petit family murders — a case that shattered the illusion of safety in a quiet Connecticut suburb. In 2007, Jennifer Hawke‑Petit was followed home by two men who would go on to hold her, her husband William Petit, and their daughters Hayley and Michaela captive through a prolonged, calculated nightmare.

And That’s Why We Drink – EP 477: Rat Directions and Pantsless Ghost Hunts

April 6, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #AndThatsWhyWeDrink –

It’s Episode 477 and Em and Christine are in full ADHD spring‑cleaning mode. Em kicks things off with a palate‑cleanser: the lore of “The Monkey’s Paw,” the classic story they somehow never actually read growing up. Then Christine covers the tragic and unsettling deaths of Debby and Mark Constantino — well‑known in the paranormal community and friends of Zak Bagans.

Two Girls One Ghost – REAL Ghost Caught on Camera 15,000 Times?! | The Polaroid Ghost & Glassell Park Haunting (Ep 367)

April 6, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #TwoGirlsOneGhost –

What if a ghost could text back… but only through Polaroids? This is the unforgettable case of the “Polaroid Ghost.” Two artists living in a quiet Los Angeles neighborhood begin documenting a presence that doesn’t just appear on camera — it responds, spells out its name, and hints at secrets buried on the property.

Avery After Dark – Appalachia’s Scariest True Paranormal Encounters

April 6, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #AveryAfterDark –

Deep in the Appalachian Mountains, there are places where the rules don’t apply… and the deeper you go, the worse it gets.

Morbid – Episode 772: The Perron Family Haunting

April 6, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #Morbid –

When Carolyn and Roger Perron moved into a small farmhouse in Harrisville, Rhode Island, they believed they’d found the perfect home for their family of seven. But the dream quickly curdled into a nightmare. What began as small disturbances — disembodied voices, foul odors, and fleeting shadows — escalated into violent hauntings, physical attacks, and encounters with something far darker than lingering spirits.

Avery After Dark – This Room Is So HAUNTED, Authorities Sealed It Shut After 2 DEATHS

April 3, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #AveryAfterDark –

What really happened inside Room 428?

In this episode, we’re diving into one of the most disturbing haunted room cases ever reported — a location so terrifying that authorities were forced to permanently seal it shut after multiple unexplained deaths.

Kimbyrleigha – Pregnant & Found Dead Two Days Before Giving Birth: Monster at Her Doorstep | Melissa Lamesch

April 3, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #Kimbyrleigha –

Two Girls One Ghost – True Ghost Stories | From Stadium Creatures To Spirit Signs… Sports Encounters (X325)

April 3, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #TwoGirlsOneGhost –

Grab your peanuts & cracker jacks because we’re reading listener stories all about sports superstitions and paranormal encounters. We might not know that much about sports, but we do know a thing or two about spirits. When you combine high stakes games, roaring crowds, and deeply rooted rituals, it’s no surprise a few spirits make an appearance.

Heart Starts Pounding w/ Kaelyn Moore – The Unsolved Disappearance That Still Haunts the Pacific Northwest

April 3, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #HeartStartsPounding –

In March 2000, 23‑year‑old Leah Roberts left a note for her roommate and took off on a solo cross‑country trip. Nine days later, her wrecked Jeep was discovered at the bottom of a ravine in Washington — and Leah was nowhere to be found. What first appeared to be an accident quickly grew darker as investigators uncovered troubling inconsistencies and unanswered questions. More than 25 years later, the mystery only deepens.

True Crime w/ Anna Templeton – The Fox Hollow Killer: Bodies in His Backyard

April 3, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #AnnaTempleton –

He looked like a normal family man… but behind that house was a backyard graveyard. For years, people walked past it — never realising what was buried just beneath their feet.

Herb Baumeister lived what appeared to be a quiet, ordinary life in Indiana — a successful businessman, a husband, a father. But beneath that carefully constructed image was a double life hiding something far more sinister.

Lauren the Mortician – People Think This Mannequin Is A Preserved Body | Mortician Explains

March 31, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #LaurentheMortician –

EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES • MORTUARY SCIENCE DISCUSSION

Hello and welcome to Morbid Monday…

I have heard this story over and over again—

that this mannequin… isn’t a mannequin.

That she was preserved after death and placed in a shop window for the world to see.

Two Girls One Ghost – The NYC Psychic Who Claimed She Traveled to Other Planets | Madame Vesta (Ep 366)

March 30, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #TwoGirlsOneGhost – #MadameVesta –

Meet Madame Vesta La Viesta, a trailblazing mystic and self-proclaimed astral traveler who fascinated early 20th-century New York City with her cosmic adventures and spiritual teachings. As a star instructor at Harlem’s Occult School of Science, she claimed her spirit could leave her body and explore distant planets. Her otherworldly encounters included extraterrestrial beings, soul-mated couples, and the intimate phenomenon she called the “soul kiss.”

True Crime w/ Anna Templeton – The Worst Case of Injustice I’ve Ever Covered

March 30, 2026 4 Evil Eyes

#horror – #podcasts – #AnnaTempleton –

The cannibal who walked free—and became a celebrity for his crimes. Issei Sagawa didn’t just commit the unthinkable; he turned his dark obsession into a career.

This deep dive into one of the most disturbing cases in criminal history explores the “Kobe Cannibal”—the man who murdered and consumed Renée Hartevelt in Paris, only to return to Japan as a free man and a media sensation.