The battle may have ended in 1863, but Gettysburg was left forever scarred, and forever haunted. This week, we’re stepping inside the Tillie Pierce House Inn, where guests encounter phantom soldiers on the stairs, children laughing, shadow figures roaming the halls, and a ghost cat that loves cuddles.
If your phone rang at 3 a.m. and the caller ID said “Payphone, Rhode Island,” would you answer? This week’s encounters episode dives into haunted phone calls, cursed voicemails, creepy glitches, and spirits who are just one bad connection away. Static-filled voices, phantom landlines, Ouija board fallout, and shadow figures all collide in a collection of listener stories guaranteed to make you think twice before answering an unknown number.
We found one of the most haunted and legendary bars in New Orleans, and the ghosts there never stopped partying. In this episode, we explore the wild history and lingering spirits of Cafe Lafitte in Exile, the oldest continuously operating gay bar in the United States. With reported hauntings from Tennessee Williams and Truman Capote, a ghost named Mr. Bubbles who may still be causing chaos on the dance floor.
You all asked for this paranormal fever dream, and we’re delivering. This episode is packed with haunted New Orleans encounters that will make you want to book a flight and immediately cleanse your suitcase afterward. We’re talking ghostly figures caught in cemetery photos, possible time slips in the French Quarter, voodoo museums with seriously heavy energy, a Rougarou sighting, haunted hotels, and the very real fear that something paranormal might hitch a ride home with you after a weekend in the Big Easy.
We’re heading deep into the haunted heart of Savannah, Georgia to uncover the chilling true story of the Gribble House and the brutal 1909 axe murders that left the city shaken. What starts as a tragic true crime case quickly spirals into something far stranger, complete with ghost sightings, bloodstains that reappear on the walls, and one of the most bizarre investigation tactics we’ve ever heard of: police hiring an actor to pretend to be a ghost in hopes of scaring a confession out of the killer. Yes, really.
We went all in on the spooky this week with listener encounters that seriously tested our bravery, diving into stories of possession, demons and exorcisms. These experiences had everything that keeps us up at night, like eerie 3:33 a.m. wakeups, haunted mirrors, sleepwalking trances, years long demonic attachments, physical injuries from paranormal attacks and so much more. Plus, rare moments where protective forces intervene.
We’re sinking our teeth into all things vampires. Their dark, blood-soaked origins, the spooky, seductive legends and people who truly believe they are vampires. We explore how ancient fears, bizarre medical mysteries, and real historical events shaped the vampire lore we know and love.
We are diving into spine-tingling listener encounters where beloved pets become unexpected guardians, mediums and witnesses to the unknown, blending cozy fur-baby nostalgia with genuine terror. These psychic cats, ghostly farmhands and supernatural guard dogs remind us that animals sense far more than we ever could. And sometimes they’re the only thing standing between us and whatever is watching.
Content Warning: This episode contains detailed descriptions of abuse, domestic violence, murder of children and general violence.
In this episode, we dive into one of the most chilling and heartbreaking cases we’ve ever covered, unraveling the story of a seemingly perfect family whose reality was far darker than anyone could have imagined. We follow the timeline from the early morning hours of August 13th through the unfolding investigation, piecing together the moments, relationships, and warning signs that led to an unthinkable outcome. But beyond the true crime, there’s something else here that stopped us in our tracks.
Content Warning: This episode contains detailed descriptions of abuse, domestic violence, murder of children and general violence.
In this episode, we dive into one of the most chilling and heartbreaking cases we’ve ever covered, unraveling the story of a seemingly perfect family whose reality was far darker than anyone could have imagined. We follow the timeline from the early morning hours of August 13th through the unfolding investigation, piecing together the moments, relationships, and warning signs that led to an unthinkable outcome. But beyond the true crime, there’s something else here that stopped us in our tracks.
We like to imagine the Grim Reaper as a helpful and misunderstood entity, clocking in for a very intense job. But after these stories… we’re not so sure. We’re getting into listener encounters that range from oddly funny to deeply unsettling, all circling the same shadowy figure who seems to show up a little too early and a little too often.
*Grim Reaper appearances include: A shadowy, eight-foot figure appears beside a listener’s bed before returning in a dream to whisper “it is your time.” A hooded presence repeatedly appears throughout a listener’s life during a series of near-death experiences. An unseen “man in black” pacing closer and closer to a hospital patient throughout a nurse’s shift before the patient suddenly passes. A hooded entity sitting beside an apparition of a deceased relative at a funeral, sharing a quiet, eerie moment before vanishing.*
Book mentioned: Under the Whispering Door by TJ Klune
In the second installment of this two-parter, we pick up right where we left off with Harold, and things immediately spiral. Anthony starts traveling with the doll, capturing EVPs that range from aggressive threats to disturbingly crude commentary. Psychics refuse to be in the same room as Harold, one woman is physically bitten during a tarot reading, and a Ouija board session reveals a spirit named Adam before leaving a deep scratch across a participant’s body. Harold isn’t just haunted, he’s active, reactive, and escalating.
It’s time for one of our favorite topics: creepy kid encounters. We’ve received countless stories of children chatting casually with deceased relatives and questionable entities, and even kids who are the subject of full-on paranormal interventions that leave physical marks. Kids seem especially tuned into the supernatural, whether they are being protected, targeted, or something in between.
What began as a gimmick to sell an old doll on eBay quickly spiraled into one of the most infamous haunted-object cases ever documented. Harold the Haunted Doll was soon linked to tragedy, with at least two people dying shortly after encountering him, and EVP evidence suggesting multiple spirits may be attached to the doll. In this first installment of a two‑part deep dive, the hosts explore Harold’s disturbing journey to his current owner, Anthony Quinata, whose book details years of hauntings, possessions, threats, and unexplained phenomena. Harold’s story remains one of the strangest and most unsettling cases Two Girls One Ghost has ever covered.
We are diving headfirst into your haunted evidence this week and let’s just say… you delivered. From crystal‑clear ghost photobombs in broad daylight to EVPs that feel highly intentional, we explore chilling proof that the paranormal is not just lurking, it’s interacting.
Content Warning: This episode contains discussions of accidental death and multiple suicides of minors.
A beloved high school principal — trusted, respected, and seen as a mentor — begins using hypnosis to help teens with anxiety, performance, and pain. It sounds harmless… until the truth behind those closed‑door sessions begins to surface. Altered states. Missing memories. Emotional detachment. And the chilling question of what happens when someone else starts rewiring your mind.
We’re diving deep into haunted New England, where eerie backroads, historic buildings, and long‑forgotten spirits collide. Ancient elemental spirits, haunted institutions, and eras‑old buildings filled with lingering energy and gin‑drinking spirits — these stories blend history, horror, and the psychologically unsettling.
We take you to the Isle of Wight, where a quiet afternoon turns into something straight out of a fever dream…or a Stephen King novel. Two kids follow a strange, siren-like sound into the woods and come face to face with a bizarre, clown-like entity who introduces himself as “all colors, Sam.” Despite his inhuman movements and unusual appearance, Sam seems friendly, inviting them into his metallic hut and admitting that he’s afraid of adult humans.
Corinne’s hairiest bestie is back! This week we dive into listener stories of Bigfoot encounters that are chilling, hilarious, and seriously hard to explain. Are these beings cryptids, ancient forest creatures, or something even stranger slipping between dimensions? We’re not totally sure, but one thing is clear: they love a snack and might just be the undefeated champions of hide and seek.
Tucked away in a tiny Indiana town, the Rhodes Hotel has lived many lives since 1893. What began as a glamorous Victorian inn during the gas boom era transformed into a brothel and speakeasy when times got tough. These days, it’s known for something much darker. Guests report footsteps in empty halls, full conversations with no one there, shadow figures lingering just out of sight, and the unmistakable feeling of being watched… or even grabbed.
Connection doesn’t end with death, and some relationships begin before you even meet… We’re sharing listener stories of loved ones reaching through the vale and across time and space, through signs, dream visits, and unexplainable moments. Sometimes in beautiful ways and sometimes in ways that are a little more eerie than comforting.
Episode 124: Meredith travels to Chattanooga, Tennessee to join Sabrina from “Two Girls One Ghost” and stay in haunted ROOM 311 of the Read House Hotel. Spoooooky. Legend says the ghost of Annalisa Netherly haunts the halls. Will they make it through the night? Will they watch “Heated Rivalry” with a nearly 100-year-old ghost? Tune in and see. But don’t touch Meredith’s toes. That’s OFF LIMITS. Stop it.
What if a ghost could text back… but only through Polaroids? This is the unforgettable case of the “Polaroid Ghost.” Two artists living in a quiet Los Angeles neighborhood begin documenting a presence that doesn’t just appear on camera — it responds, spells out its name, and hints at secrets buried on the property.
Grab your peanuts & cracker jacks because we’re reading listener stories all about sports superstitions and paranormal encounters. We might not know that much about sports, but we do know a thing or two about spirits. When you combine high stakes games, roaring crowds, and deeply rooted rituals, it’s no surprise a few spirits make an appearance.
Meet Madame Vesta La Viesta, a trailblazing mystic and self-proclaimed astral traveler who fascinated early 20th-century New York City with her cosmic adventures and spiritual teachings. As a star instructor at Harlem’s Occult School of Science, she claimed her spirit could leave her body and explore distant planets. Her otherworldly encounters included extraterrestrial beings, soul-mated couples, and the intimate phenomenon she called the “soul kiss.”